Call 24/7
North Carolina Criminal Defense AttorneyProtecting Good People During Hard Times

Home›Guides›Consent, alcohol and memory

How do consent, alcohol and memory affect sex crime charges in North Carolina?

In North Carolina, sex is "against the will" of another person if there was no consent or if consent was revoked in a way a reasonable person would recognize. Since 2019, a person can be "mentally incapacitated" from alcohol or drugs they chose to use, and the accused can be charged if they knew or should have known it.

Last updated · Reviewed by the Marketing Team · Statutes cited from the North Carolina General Assembly (ncleg.gov)

What does consent mean under North Carolina law?

The statutes define "against the will of the other person" as either without consent, or after consent is revoked "in a manner that would cause a reasonable person to believe consent is revoked" (G.S. 14-27.20(1a)). So consent given at the start can be withdrawn, and continuing after a clear withdrawal can be a crime.

When does alcohol make someone unable to consent?

A person is "mentally incapacitated" if, "due to any act," they are rendered substantially incapable of appraising the nature of their conduct or resisting the act (14-27.20(2)). That wording, from S.L. 2019-245 (offenses on or after December 1, 2019), covers incapacity from alcohol or drugs the person took voluntarily, not only substances given to them by someone else. Being drunk is not automatically incapacity; the question is whether the person was substantially incapable.

"Physically helpless" means unconscious, or physically unable to resist or to communicate unwillingness (14-27.20(3)).

What charges can apply?

Charges involving incapacity or lack of consent
ChargeStatuteClass
Second-degree forcible rape (by force and against the will, or with a person who is mentally incapacitated or physically helpless)G.S. 14-27.22Class C felony
Second-degree forcible sexual offense (same, for a sexual act)G.S. 14-27.27Class C felony
Sexual battery (sexual contact by force and against the will, or with an incapacitated or helpless person)G.S. 14-27.33Class A1 misdemeanor
First-degree forcible rape or sexual offense (with a weapon, serious injury, or aided by others)G.S. 14-27.21, 14-27.26Class B1 felony

For the incapacity versions, the State must prove the accused knew or should reasonably have known the other person was incapacitated or helpless.

What if one or both people do not remember?

Memory gaps cut both ways. A complainant's lack of memory may be offered as evidence of incapacity, but not remembering is not the same as having been substantially incapable at the time. Evidence such as texts, ride-share and phone data, video, witness accounts of how each person was acting, and toxicology often matters more than anyone's recollection. If the accused was also drinking, voluntary intoxication generally is not a defense to the "should reasonably have known" standard.

Can the complainant's past be used as evidence?

Usually not. North Carolina's rape shield rule, Rule 412, makes the complainant's other sexual behavior irrelevant except in narrow situations, such as prior sexual behavior between the complainant and the defendant, or evidence offered to show someone else committed the act. The court decides admissibility outside the jury's presence.

What should you do if you are accused?

  • Do not contact the accuser or send messages explaining yourself.
  • Preserve your phone data, messages, and location history; do not delete anything.
  • Do not agree to a police interview without a lawyer.
  • Write down a timeline for your lawyer only.

We defend sex crime charges across our 30-county service area, including Mecklenburg County, Wake County, Durham County, Orange County, Gaston County, Cabarrus County, plus Charlotte, Raleigh and Cary. See all counties we serve. Learn more on our sex crimes defense page.

Talk to a North Carolina criminal defense attorney today. Charlotte and Belmont: (704) 842-3411 (Charlotte/Belmont). Raleigh and Cary: (919) 925-4613 (Raleigh/Triangle). Phones answered 24/7, and your first case review is free. Consultations are by phone or video.

Protecting Good People During Hard Times.

Request a free case review Call (704) 842-3411

Related guides

Frequently asked questions

Can someone withdraw consent in North Carolina?

Yes. Under G.S. 14-27.20(1a), continuing after consent is revoked in a way a reasonable person would recognize is "against the will."

Can a drunk person legally consent in NC?

Being drunk does not automatically remove the ability to consent. The question is whether the person was substantially incapable of appraising the conduct or resisting.

Does voluntary intoxication count as mental incapacity?

For offenses on or after December 1, 2019, yes. The definition covers incapacity "due to any act," including the person's own drinking or drug use.

What must the State prove about the accused's knowledge?

That the accused knew or should reasonably have known the other person was mentally incapacitated or physically helpless.

What is the penalty for second-degree rape in NC?

It is a Class C felony under G.S. 14-27.22.

Is sexual battery a felony?

No, it is a Class A1 misdemeanor under G.S. 14-27.33, but it usually requires sex offender registration.

Can the accuser's sexual history be used?

Only in narrow situations allowed by Rule 412, decided by the judge outside the jury's presence.